I was most fortunate to acquire this week two extremely well preserved lps of George Szell conducting in Cleveland (1952) and New York (1954ish I think). Here they are and, for the first time, I am trying ClickRepair in its trial edition.
Szell is rather interesting character in my book. An incredibly gifted musician (many do not realize that he was a piano prodigy and composer), he was also a difficult, rather mean spirited man, who sought only to promote his ambitions, often at the expense of weaker and sometimes less talented musicians. Given what I have read, it seems that no really liked Szell but his willful personality manipulated and cajoled those around him into doing his bidding. At its very best, the results of the Szell way was unparalleled excitement coupled with breathtaking musical virtuosity and execution.
The Schumann from Cleveland is Szell's first take on the work with this orchestra. Those that know his celebrated cycle from the late 50's, early 60's may not recognize this as being from the same conductor,or orchestra for that matter! This is highly driven performance from an orchestra that is not quite the precise ensemble it would become within the next 8 to 10 years of this recording. Without a doubt, Szell blows off whatever cobwebs his predecessors laid on the work and he presents a blazing account of a rather wonderful score. I have never heard a Schumann 2nd that moves like a great performance of a Beethoven symphony..but this one does!
Beethoven's Pastorale from New York is noticably more restrained than the Schumann but features more secure playing and a warmer touch. Like Szell's later Cleveland account, this is a good reading but the maestro's temperament is somewhat at odds with the general flavor of the score. I've always thought that a more genial Walter way or, expansive Stokowski vision, works best in this colorful music. Szell doesn't strike me as a man who had much to do with nature...could you imagine him fly fishing? Whatever the final verdict, Szell does deliver Beethoven with an overall faithful approach to the score. Surprisingly, I hear portamento from the strings and THAT was a bit of a surprise....maybe Szell was indeed relaxing a bit!?
DOWNLOAD BEETHOVEN
DOWNLOAD SCHUMANN










