Robert Shaw made two recordings of Brahms' masterpiece Ein Deutsches Requiem. Though separated by some 35 years, both represent well Shaw's devotion to the score and his understanding of the deep sense of humanity captured in the words and brilliantly supported by the music. Here from 1948 is the first recording with Shaw leading the RCA Victor Chorale and Orchestra with soloists Eleanor Steber and James Pease.
Robert Shaw was a remarkable man. When I was in college, he visited and gave several lectures which culminated in a marvelous performance of Bach's St Matthew Passion. What struck me most about Shaw was his inner strength and spirtuality. His communicative style was based on personal reflection and the need to include everyone in the dialogue while his words were measured, humble, yet authoritative. I found him to be a man that spoke to one's soul through music and philosophy in an engaging, inclusive manner. Truly a wonderful human being.
Perhaps Shaw's personal characteristics play a major, if not pivotal role, in the interpretation of this Brahms masterwork. I find the sense of "line" to be just right and the singing is impassioned with a lyric gentleness to it. Though the RCA Victor orchestra cannot match the tonal lushness of the later Atlanta Symphony, these seasoned musicians from the Philharmonic and NBC Symphony propel the music along nimbly and with a lean sound they prevent the "full cries" of the chorus from becoming garbled and bloated. Though other conductors might have more outward passion, listening to this and the later recording are antidotes to a world of rush, rush, rush and grave inpersonalism.
DOWNLOAD
